Hockey Players Club Blog - We love talking hockey! Hockey tips, NHL discussion, and funny hockey talk.

The Ten Best Hockey Fights of All Time

Hockey season may be right around the corner but that doesn’t soothe the current pain of waking up every day to no hockey. One of the things missed most by its enthusiasts is a good old-fashioned hockey fight. While some people claim it’s barbaric and there’s no place for it in the game, others swear the self-policing keeps players safe and honest.

Regardless of which opinion you side with, a rich history of fisticuffs in hockey dates back to the 19th century. The NHL officially introduced Rule 56 in 1922, formally regulating fighting in the official NHL rulebook.  Almost a hundred years and countless fights later, we, the Hockey Players Club, created our list of the best hockey fights of all time.

“Good Friday Brawl” Quebec Nordiques vs Montreal Canadiens – April 20, 1984

Anytime you get a bunch of Canadian hockey players together, someone’s getting punched in the face. This was the case on Good Friday back in 1984 where everyone was swarming more than Dead Heads at a Grateful Dead concert.

Bob Probert vs Craig Coxe – November 11, 1985

Nothing better than two men throwing nonstop punches for 40 seconds.

Boston Bruins vs New York Rangers – December 23, 1979

Any time a player goes into the stands to fight a fan it’s memorable, but when the whole team does… it’s legendary. That was the case at Madison Square Garden back in 1979. The best part of this altercation may be Mike Milbury hitting a fan with the fan’s own shoe…classic!

Tony Twist vs Rob Ray – November 27, 1995

Tony Twist may be a goofy name but there’s nothing goofy about this fight. A massive, one-sided win for Twist which left Ray with numerous facial fractures.

Bob Probert vs Marty McSorley – February 4, 1994

Hockeyfights.com gave this fight a 9.6 out of 10 rating. This is the dime piece of hockey fights.

Brent Johnson vs Rick DiPietro – February 2, 2011

R.I.P. to Rick DiPetro’s orbital bone and career.


“Brawl in Hockeytown” Detroit Red Wings vs Colorado Avalanche – March 26, 1997

In response to Claude Lemieux’s vicious hit on Kris Draper, these two squads hold absolutely nothing back. Plus, bonus commentary of Don Cherry calling Claude a turtle. Legendary.

Philadelphia Flyers vs Ottawa Senators – March 5, 2004

Metallica playing in the background, Rob Ray v. Donald Brashear, a line brawl, and a goalie fight… are you not entertained?!?!?!

Pittsburgh Penguins vs. New York Islanders – February 11, 2011

Fueled by a hate-filled game 9 days prior, these two two teams racked up 8 fighting majors and a staggering 346 minutes of penalties combined.

Bob Nystrom vs John Wensink – April 17, 1980

We’re not sure what’s better: the nonstop barrage of punches or John Wensink’s afro. Either way, classic tilt.

What legendary hockey fight did we miss? Comment below!


Are you a member of the awesome hockey tape subscription service, the Hockey Players Club? If not, save yourself time and money and join today!

✔ Pause or cancel anytime.
✔ No commitments. No hidden fees. No BS.
✔ Customize your package and shipping frequency (1 to 6 months).

The Hockey Players Club subscription hockey tape box is a fast growing service that delivers hockey tape and other hockey essentials straight to your door on a monthly basis.

Comments are closed.